Owl of the Desert
  • Home
  • Poetry
    • Fleeing Egypt >
      • Tower of Babel
      • The Orchard
      • Tithing Settlement
      • Chastity for Churches
      • Sign
      • Cleaning House
      • Elijah
      • Rulers of Sodom
      • Beware
      • Two Churches
      • Beginning At My Sanctuary
      • Toll Road
      • Get it Strait
      • Corporation Sole
      • The Religion of the Circle R
      • Fig Tree
      • Eve
      • New Jerusalem
      • Shemlon's Shore
    • Ascending Sinai >
      • Ark
      • Sin of the Calf
      • An Idol Observation
      • Dew from Heaven
      • I love you, Elder Holland
      • Easter
      • How Sweet
      • Haiku
      • The Barn
      • Patron Saint
      • A Conversation with Brigham Young
      • Mine Testimony
      • The Meadow
      • The Gardens
      • Ice Fishing
      • Without End
      • Forest
      • Continental Divide
      • A Great Sacrifice
    • Promised Land >
      • Lanolin
      • Zion
      • Wisdom
      • Take Up Your Cross
      • Was the Sun the Same
      • Plain and Precious
      • Bridegroom
      • Faith
      • Amos
      • But First
      • Wax
      • Parable of the Piano
      • Repentance
      • Wake Up, Child
      • Cold Storage
      • Covered Wagon
      • Multiply and Replenish
      • Rollercoaster
      • The Baptist
    • Seven Stations of the Cross >
      • Jesus Condemned to Die >
        • Life Signs
        • Fashionable Religion
        • Tithing Declaration
        • A Pretty Important Detail
        • Jesus is All
        • Salt Lake Temple
        • Zion in the Lion's Den
        • High Noon
        • Bookmark
      • Jesus Stumbles and Falls >
        • Unveil
        • But Faith
        • Sifting
        • The Ballerina
        • Credit Declined
        • Prayer Circles
        • Work Out Your Salvation
        • Lovebirds
        • Unrequited
      • Simon of Cyrene Bears the Cross >
        • Proxy
        • Chartres
        • Like the Nile
        • Artificial Intelligence
        • Not Born
        • Parable of the Crossing
      • Women of Jerusalem Weep >
        • With A Price
        • Fields of Asphodel
        • Night
        • Desert Rose
        • Goodbye
        • Spring Snow
      • Jesus Stripped of His Garment >
        • Love Letter
        • I am disquieted
        • Dream
        • Noah's Wife
        • Parable of the Five Sons
        • Eggshell
      • Jesus Nailed to the Cross
      • Burial and Resurrection
  • Blog
    • Previous Posts >
      • 2025 Posts
      • 2024 Posts
      • 2023 Posts
      • 2022 Posts
      • 2021 Posts
      • 2020 Posts
  • About
  • Contact



   
    
​

"Thou Hast Made an End of Tithing": Part 5

10/2/2020

2 Comments

 
Picture
Going Out of Business

Extra! Extra! Read all about it!  Runaway Bride leaves Great Whore at the altar!  Church decides to divorce Babylon! 

Extra! Extra!  Church to go out of business.  Church to make new start without Mammon's financial support, even if it has to move into Father's basement in the wilderness. 

Sectarianism

An Ohio State University study found that 60% of restaurants fail during their first year, and 80% of restaurants close within five years of opening.  

Why do so many restaurants shut down?  Well, it all boils down to one reason: lack of paying customers.  

The restaurant world, like the religious world, is highly competitive.  About 5,000 congregations in the U.S. disappear every year.

Sectarianism is religion's bread-and-butter.  As Joseph Smith experienced, "When the converts began to file off, some to one party and some to another, it was seen that the seemingly good feelings of both the priests and the converts were more pretended than real; for a scene of great confusion and bad feeling ensued" (JS-H 1:6).

Where is the profit in love, in charity, in sacrifice, in equality?  If we want to bring in the big bucks from financial donors, it helps to have an "us vs. them" mentality, perhaps a persecution complex; a sense of superiority; a platform for declaring we have a monopoly on God's favor, whilst others are fools.  (How else could the Great and Spacious Building operate?  The Condominium Association Fees alone are exorbitant.)

The thing that generates revenue is the rivalry!  Are McDonald's french fries better than Wendy's?  Is Popeye's chicken sandwich juicier than Chick-fil-A's?  You see, we have to draw lines, take sides, and create division over stuff that doesn't matter.  

But the stakes are greater in religion than in fast food.  If I stop going to McDonald's and begin eating lunch at Taco Bell, no one will care.  But guess how families and friends will react if we stop attending Kingdom Hall with the Jehovah's Witnesses and start attending Mormonism?  Or if a Scientologist converts to Methodism?  Or if an Amish girl becomes Catholic?

All hell breaks loose.  And sometimes families shun their loved one for exercising their God-given agency and religious autonomy. 

We find that we do not really believe Article of Faith 11 after all.  We give it lip service:

   We claim the privilege
   of worshiping Almighty God
   according to the dictates
   of our own conscience,
   and allow all men
   the same privilege,
   let them worship how,
   where, or what they may.

How does God respond to Sectarianism?   

   Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees,
   hypocrites! for ye compass sea
   and land to make one proselyte,
   and when he is made,
   ye make him twofold more
   the child of hell than yourselves.

(Matt. 23:15)

Should we join Joseph Smith in the sentiment, "I had now got my mind satisfied so far as the sectarian world was concerned -- that it was not my duty to join with any of them, but to continue as I was until further directed" (JS-H 1:26).
Picture
Beneficial Life Insurance Company 

What is the difference between a convert and a customer? 

One of the businesses the LDS Church owns is the for-profit Beneficial Life Insurance Company.  I find it beautifully ironic: a church owning a life insurance company.  

This is how life insurance works:  You purchase life insurance by signing a contract with an insurance company.  In exchange for your regular premium payments, the insurance company will write a check after you die to your beneficiaries.  The benefit of life insurance is that you leave behind a financial cushion for your loved ones. 

This is how religion works:  You purchase an eternal life insurance policy by joining a church that promises you that they have the One-True-Way.  In exchange for your regular tithing payments, the church assures you that you will go to heaven when you die.  The benefit of an eternal life insurance policy is you have peace of mind while living.  

Notice, though, religion doesn't have to write a check when you die.

​Sectarianism is Big Business

According to the Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on Religion, the "faith-based economy" in the United States is worth about $1.2 Trillion Dollars.  (http://www.religjournal.com/pdf/ijrr12003.pdf)
Picture
Priestcraft

The primary tenet of Priestcraft is 'you can buy anything in this world with money.'

The very best definition of Priestcraft I have found is from Nephi:

   God commandeth that there shall be
   no priestcrafts; for, behold, priestcrafts
   are that:

    (1) men preach and set themselves up
    for a light unto the world,
 
    (2) that they may get gain

    (3) and praise of the world;

   but they seek not the welfare of Zion.
   Behold, the Lord hath forbidden
   this thing; wherefore, the Lord God
   hath given a commandment
   that all men should have charity,
   which charity is love.
   And except they should have charity
   they were nothing.

​(2 Nephi 26:29-30)

Notice how the opposite of Priestcraft is Charity?  

So let's look and see how our churches fare.  How charitable are our churches?  Do they:

    (1) Suffereth long?

    (2) Is kind?

    (3) Envieth not?

    (4) Is not puffed up?

    (5) Seeketh not her own?

    (6) Is not easily provoked?

    (7) Thinketh no evil?

    (8) Rejoiceth not in iniquity?

    (9) Rejoiceth in the truth?

    (10) Beareth all things?

    (11) Believeth all things?

    (12) Hopeth all things; and

    (13) Endureth all things?
Picture
One Ring to Rule Them All

In the Lord of the Rings, the evil lord Satan . . . I mean, Sauron, crafts a Master Ring to rule all Middle Earth. 

   One Ring to rule them all,
   One Ring to find them,
   One Ring to bring them all
   And in the darkness bind them.

Priestcraft is the "One Ring" of religion, the means by which we can have our cake and eat it too.  The way we can promise followers an eternal reward . . . for a price.

If we can buy anything in this world with money, why not eternal life?

Nehor

Nehor was a priest who had great success.  He declared that every priest and teacher ought to become popular; that they ought not labor with their hands, but should be supported by the people (Alma 1). 

Instead of sacrifice, he wanted a salary.

Contrast Nehor with Nephi, who taught:

   My beloved brethren,
   the Lord God worketh
   not in darkness.


   He doeth not anything
   save it be for the benefit
   of the world; for he loveth
   the world, even that he
   layeth down his own life
   that he may draw call men
   unto him. Wherefore, he
   commandeth none
   that they shall not partake
   of his salvation.

   Behold, doth he cry unto any,
   saying: Depart from me?
   Behold, I say unto you, Nay;
   but he saith: Come unto me
   all ye ends of the earth,
   buy milk and honey,
   without money and without price.

(2 Nephi 26:23-25)

Instead of getting rich, Christ got dead.  Instead of taking our money, Christ gave his to the poor and needy. 
Picture
"Darkness" vs. Transparency

​The Lord loves honesty.  He loves transparency, which leads to accountability.  The Spirit of Christ is open, true and light.

   Jesus answered him,
   I spake openly to the world;
   I ever taught in the synagogue,
   and in the temple,
   whither the Jews always resort;
   and in secret have I said nothing.

(John 18:20)

On the other hand, it seems like the Lord really dislikes his children trying to hide in the dark, keeping secrets from each other.

   Their iniquities shall be spoken
   upon the housetops,
   and their secret acts
   shall be revealed.

(D&C 1:3)

That is why the Lord commands common consent.  How can a church call itself Christian if it does not operate transparently?  According to Jesus:

   And he said unto them,
   Is a candle brought
   to be put under a bushel,
   or under a bed?
   and not to be set
   on a candlestick?

   For there is nothing hid,
   which shall not be manifested;
   neither was any thing kept secret,
   but that it should come abroad.

(Mark 4:21-22)

On the other hand, secret combinations love to keep their works hidden in the dark.

   And it shall come in a day
   when the blood of saints
   shall cry unto the Lord,
   because of secret combinations
   and the works of darkness.

   Yea, it shall come in a day
   when the power of God
   shall be denied, and churches
   become defiled and be lifted up
   in the pride of their hearts;
   yea, even in a day when leaders
   of churches
and teachers
   shall rise in the pride of their hearts,
   even to the envying of them
   who belong to their churches.

   Yea, it shall come in a day
   when there shall be churches
   built up that shall say:
   Come unto me,
   and for your money
   you shall be forgiven

   of your sins.

   O ye wicked and perverse
   and stiffnecked people,
   why have ye built up churches
   unto yourselves to get gain?


(Mormon 8:27-28, 32-33)

Conclusion

My friends, I do believe Moroni was speaking to us.  Have we read the headlines lately?

I think it is time we took a serious look in the mirror.  Would we pass a Priestcraft Test?
Picture
2 Comments
Eben
11/25/2023 09:08:52 am

Thank you for this fantastic series! It's time to cast off the false traditions of our fathers and be free! Tithing has always been a box to check to easily prove how "faithful" I am, but actually helping the poor, individually, face to face, is so much more powerful and meaningful. I don't think tithing helps us develope charity for our brothers and sisters... And shouldn't that be the point?

Reply
Tim Merrill
11/29/2023 01:26:20 pm

Thank you Eben! Your insight is top-shelf, I cannot emphasize it enough, that "tithing [doesn't] help us develop charity for our brothers and sisters." You hit the bullseye!

One time, many years ago, I was driving home from Moab with my wife and we spent hours talking about tithing. I made a list of the "problems" with it (which I guess were the seeds of this Series), but the most fundamental flaw of surrogated-giving (as we see in government welfare) is it does not bring neighbors closer together.

When I was newlywed and we were expecting our first baby, I dropped out of school and took a job. No way we could pay $5,000 for the hospital and doctor (our co-pay). One of the hardest things I've ever had to do is approach my family members and ask for financial assistance. They gave it, and guess what? Their generosity bloomed into an abiding love, that they took care of me in my time of need. It made me hope, one day, to be able to return the favor.

The principle of tithing impoverishes us as a people by limiting those with meager means from individually seeking inspiration in how to give. Those who are moderately well off may say, "But Tim, why not do both? Why not pay tithing AND give extra to those in need?" I love that question because I flip it around:

"Okay, but why pay tithing FIRST? Why not give generously to those in need FIRST and then pay tithing afterwards?"

That stops them in their tracks, because it shows where our heart is: in earning institutional blessings over those of our Father.

Anyway, you inspired me with your brief comment. Thank you! Tim

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Tim Merrill

    RSS Feed

    Previous Posts

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020

    RSS Feed

    Previous Posts
Home
© COPYRIGHT 2019 - 2025
  • Home
  • Poetry
    • Fleeing Egypt >
      • Tower of Babel
      • The Orchard
      • Tithing Settlement
      • Chastity for Churches
      • Sign
      • Cleaning House
      • Elijah
      • Rulers of Sodom
      • Beware
      • Two Churches
      • Beginning At My Sanctuary
      • Toll Road
      • Get it Strait
      • Corporation Sole
      • The Religion of the Circle R
      • Fig Tree
      • Eve
      • New Jerusalem
      • Shemlon's Shore
    • Ascending Sinai >
      • Ark
      • Sin of the Calf
      • An Idol Observation
      • Dew from Heaven
      • I love you, Elder Holland
      • Easter
      • How Sweet
      • Haiku
      • The Barn
      • Patron Saint
      • A Conversation with Brigham Young
      • Mine Testimony
      • The Meadow
      • The Gardens
      • Ice Fishing
      • Without End
      • Forest
      • Continental Divide
      • A Great Sacrifice
    • Promised Land >
      • Lanolin
      • Zion
      • Wisdom
      • Take Up Your Cross
      • Was the Sun the Same
      • Plain and Precious
      • Bridegroom
      • Faith
      • Amos
      • But First
      • Wax
      • Parable of the Piano
      • Repentance
      • Wake Up, Child
      • Cold Storage
      • Covered Wagon
      • Multiply and Replenish
      • Rollercoaster
      • The Baptist
    • Seven Stations of the Cross >
      • Jesus Condemned to Die >
        • Life Signs
        • Fashionable Religion
        • Tithing Declaration
        • A Pretty Important Detail
        • Jesus is All
        • Salt Lake Temple
        • Zion in the Lion's Den
        • High Noon
        • Bookmark
      • Jesus Stumbles and Falls >
        • Unveil
        • But Faith
        • Sifting
        • The Ballerina
        • Credit Declined
        • Prayer Circles
        • Work Out Your Salvation
        • Lovebirds
        • Unrequited
      • Simon of Cyrene Bears the Cross >
        • Proxy
        • Chartres
        • Like the Nile
        • Artificial Intelligence
        • Not Born
        • Parable of the Crossing
      • Women of Jerusalem Weep >
        • With A Price
        • Fields of Asphodel
        • Night
        • Desert Rose
        • Goodbye
        • Spring Snow
      • Jesus Stripped of His Garment >
        • Love Letter
        • I am disquieted
        • Dream
        • Noah's Wife
        • Parable of the Five Sons
        • Eggshell
      • Jesus Nailed to the Cross
      • Burial and Resurrection
  • Blog
    • Previous Posts >
      • 2025 Posts
      • 2024 Posts
      • 2023 Posts
      • 2022 Posts
      • 2021 Posts
      • 2020 Posts
  • About
  • Contact