Owl of the Desert
  • Home
  • Poetry
    • Fleeing Egypt >
      • Tower of Babel
      • The Orchard
      • Tithing Settlement
      • Chastity for Churches
      • Sign
      • Cleaning House
      • Elijah
      • Rulers of Sodom
      • Beware
      • Two Churches
      • Beginning At My Sanctuary
      • Toll Road
      • Get it Strait
      • Corporation Sole
      • The Religion of the Circle R
      • Fig Tree
      • Eve
      • New Jerusalem
      • Shemlon's Shore
    • Ascending Sinai >
      • Ark
      • Sin of the Calf
      • An Idol Observation
      • Dew from Heaven
      • I love you, Elder Holland
      • Easter
      • How Sweet
      • Haiku
      • The Barn
      • Patron Saint
      • A Conversation with Brigham Young
      • Mine Testimony
      • The Meadow
      • The Gardens
      • Ice Fishing
      • Without End
      • Forest
      • Continental Divide
      • A Great Sacrifice
    • Promised Land >
      • Lanolin
      • Zion
      • Wisdom
      • Take Up Your Cross
      • Was the Sun the Same
      • Plain and Precious
      • Bridegroom
      • Faith
      • Amos
      • But First
      • Wax
      • Parable of the Piano
      • Repentance
      • Wake Up, Child
      • Cold Storage
      • Covered Wagon
      • Multiply and Replenish
      • Rollercoaster
      • The Baptist
    • Seven Stations of the Cross >
      • Jesus Condemned to Die >
        • Life Signs
        • Fashionable Religion
        • Tithing Declaration
        • A Pretty Important Detail
        • Jesus is All
        • Salt Lake Temple
        • Zion in the Lion's Den
        • High Noon
        • Bookmark
      • Jesus Stumbles and Falls >
        • Unveil
        • But Faith
        • Sifting
        • The Ballerina
        • Credit Declined
        • Prayer Circles
        • Work Out Your Salvation
        • Lovebirds
        • Unrequited
      • Simon of Cyrene Bears the Cross >
        • Proxy
        • Chartres
        • Like the Nile
        • Artificial Intelligence
        • Not Born
        • Parable of the Crossing
      • Women of Jerusalem Weep >
        • With A Price
        • Fields of Asphodel
        • Night
        • Desert Rose
        • Goodbye
        • Spring Snow
      • Jesus Stripped of His Garment >
        • Love Letter
        • I am disquieted
        • Dream
        • Noah's Wife
        • Parable of the Five Sons
        • Eggshell
      • Jesus Nailed to the Cross
      • Burial and Resurrection
  • Blog
    • Previous Posts >
      • 2025 Posts
      • 2024 Posts
      • 2023 Posts
      • 2022 Posts
      • 2021 Posts
      • 2020 Posts
  • About
  • Contact



   
    
​

Cooking with Criminals and Other Commandments: Part 2

6/7/2023

4 Comments

 
Picture
"Steadying the Ark?"  Yes, Please

You know who I feel sorry for?  Uzzah from the Old Testament who steadied the Ark of the Covenant (no good deed goes unpunished).

In ancient Israel, during King David's reign, Uzzah "put forth his hand to hold the ark; for the oxen stumbled" (1 Chronicles 13:9).

The Lord smote Uzzah and he died (but really, blame the clumsy oxen).

I think it's safe to assume Uzzah was an important person since he was entrusted with transporting the Ark of the Covenant (you don't let just-anybody drive the cart carrying the Lord's precious cargo; I can see the bumper sticker: "Cherubs On Board").

You may think the death penalty for something as minor as steadying the ark was a bit harsh (then again, we're talking about the law of Moses where you could be stoned for gathering firewood on the Sabbath (Numbers 15:32-36) ― especially when we consider Uzza's motives were well-intended.  Would I have done the same?  After all, nobody wants to see the ark tumble out of the wagon onto the interstate, dumping its contents of manna and rods and stone tablets and denting the angels' wings ("I know a guy who can buff that right out").

But you know the rules: only Levites could carry the ark and others were forbidden: "They shall not touch any holy thing, lest they die" (Numbers 4:15).

So what does this have to do with us? Well, the idea of "steadying the ark" has become a sort of urban legend ― a scary tale we tell our children at bedtime to caution them against questioning the way things are done in the Church.

And it's effective: just a nip of children's Tylenol, a bit of warm milk, and a terrifying tale about a vivid shaft of lightning coming to kill you if you complain.  A winning combination!

As the Church explains in its D&C Student Manual for Section 85:

"Today there are those who fear the ark is tottering and presume to steady its course. There are those who are sure that women are not being treated fairly in the Church, those who would extend some unauthorized blessing, or those who would change the established doctrines of the Church. These are ark-steadiers." 

Oh dear; am I an ark-steadier?  I toss-and-turn like a toddler in his Snoopy sheets, tucked in my bassinet so tightly I can barely breath, watching the mobile above my head circle endlessly.  The official narrative, you see, is to get us to close our eyes and go to sleep; let the leaders take care of things.

And so we drift off to sleep, riding along on the dreamy cart with the ark tucked safely in the back, without a worry in the world ― untroubled by those nasty potholes up ahead.

But does that interpretation withstand scrutiny?  
Picture
"Make Moses Great Again!"

​What's the point of being "anxiously engaged" in good causes if the Church itself is off-limits?

It's like the Brethren are saying, "Go and make the world a better place: but not here 
― not at Church where you spend half your lives.  Hands-off the Church.  The rest is fine, but do you see the NO TRESPASSING signs we've posted on the rusty barbed-wire fence around our prerogative?  We recently electrified the fence, too ― concerned for your safety, of course, because we don't want you to contract tetanus."

Well, the Doctrine and Covenants weighs in on the matter in Section 85:


   While that man,
   who was called of God
   and appointed,

   [Oh, oh, oh: so we're NOT talking about lay-members after all. This was a warning to those who were "called and appointed" ― which means it applies to the leaders, not the members]
   that putteth forth his hand
   to steady the ark of God,
   shall fall by the shaft of death,
   like as a tree that is smitten
   by the vivid shaft of lightning.


(D&C 85:8)

The point I want to make is that we have misused this metaphor by turning it on its head, giving it the opposite meaning than what the Lord intended.  Why did we do that?

Not convinced?  Take a look at this quote by Joseph Smith who personally interpreted it for us (how convenient). Joseph provided the earliest commentary we have, reported on January 1, 1834 by Oliver Cowdery in a letter to John Whitmer, specifically addressing the "steadying the ark" revelation (now D&C 85) and what it meant:

"Brother Joseph says, that the item in his letter that says, that the man that is called &c. and puts forth his hand to steady the ark of God, does not mean that any had at the time, but it was given for a caution to those in high standing to beware, lest they should fall by the vivid shaft of death as the Lord had said."

(Letter, Oliver Cowdery to John Whitmer, January 1, 1834, Huntington Library, San Marino, California.)

According to Joseph, who was the warning for?  "Those in high standing."

Okay, does that refer to the nibbling, hungry waifs who sit under the table hoping for scraps?  To us?  Nope.  So we can relax, because you and I can't steady the ark.
​
   Only the leadership can.
Picture
Summer School for the Prophets

It never ceases to amaze me how we can take things out of context to serve the interests of the establishment.  A classic example of this is the 
Joseph Smith quote that says:

"That man who rises up to condemn others, finding fault with the Church, saying that they are out of the way while he himself is righteous, then know assuredly that that man is in the high road to apostacy." (
History of the Church, 3:385).

Have you heard this quote before?  I bet you have: its fingerprints are all over the official curriculum (you'd think they'd wear gloves to better cover their tracks; but no, they don't seem worried).  Are you curious how the Church interprets this statement?  Look:

"Joseph Smith taught the importance of sustaining our Church leaders."  (Chapter 27, Teachings of the Presidents of the Church: Joseph Smith.)

Ah, I see; the Church is saying Joseph didn't want us finding fault with the Brethren and was telling us to not criticize them.  Is that right?

Umm . . . it's actually the exact opposite.  Joseph spoke these words directly to the Twelve Apostles; he was telling THEM to not find fault with "the Church."  (That's us.)

Not convinced?  Here's the historical introduction from The Joseph Smith Papers for the quote:

"JS and his counselors in the First Presidency went to the home of apostle Brigham Young in Montrose, Iowa Territory, where the presidency met with the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, the apostles’ wives, and members of the Quorums of the Seventy. This meeting was one of several convened to instruct the apostles."

(Historical Introduction to "JS, Discourse," Montrose, Lee Co., Iowa Territory, 2 July 1839; Joseph Smith Papers).

So Joseph was conducting a Leadership Training; he wasn't talking about you and me; he was addressing the Twelve, instructing THEM to stop fault-finding.

Just to calm our minds on the matter, we read in Joseph's journal for the occasion that Joseph wanted the leadership to "guard against self-righteousness and self-importance." Id.  (Was ego a problem among the Twelve then?  Is it now?)

Well, the rest is history.  The quote was turned inside-out and has imbedded itself in the Church's collective consciousness, being used to bludgeon the original meaning of what Joseph intended.  I can't make this up!

In the same way, the Church uses the story about Uzzah steadying the ark to silence criticism of leadership, to disenfranchise common consent, and to clip grassroot efforts to build Zion ― when in fact, all along, it was a warning to leaders to not trust in their own wisdom or to get in the Lord's way by mangling the affairs of the Kingdom. 

(Why are members always getting the bum rap?)
Picture
Is It Time to Steady the Ark?

Why do we fill Church curriculum with lessons about sustaining our leaders and with things like "dress modestly" ― as if the most pressing issue on the Lord's mind was whether women have exposed shoulders?

Why is our faith stuck in the past, living as if it were still 1200 B.C.?  Why does the Church want us all to be like Joshua lifting Moses' hands while battling the Amalekites instead of lifting our eyes to Christ?

God is standing beside us with a firehose of light and knowledge and truth and we want to turn off the spigot, setting fires and quibbling over coffee and caffeine?

Recently I read online a post from a reddit user which explains our predicament:

"One summer we went to Utah with our son to visit BYU, thinking one day he might go there.  We went to Deseret Towers, which is where I lived as a student.  I was full of nostalgia.  My [Catholic] wife was impressed.  Our kid was delighted at the fare offered at the Morris Center cafeteria.
 
"As we were preparing to have lunch there, a BYU employee came up and tapped my wife on the shoulder and told her she would have to leave because she was wearing a sleeveless shirt!


"It was such a humiliating moment for all of us, disorienting and anti-climactic.  We all skulked out of the Morris center and that was the end of our visit to BYU.  Definitely the end of my kid’s interest in going there, and definitely the end of my wife’s willingness to entertain the idea of being Mormon.

"Ironically, my wife is such a conservative and modest woman.  For her to be humiliated like that in front of our kid is something she has never forgotten."


Which is more important: a shoulder or a soul?
Picture
[December 2022: Church Magazines Give Mary a Lesson in Modesty.  The Church photoshopped this painting of Mary (above) to remove her cleavage.

In response, the Church's Scripture Committee revised the King James Bible to now read: "Blessed is the womb that bare thee, and the [bottle] which thou hast sucked" (Luke 11:27).


LDS Spokesperson goes on record and says the Church has no official position on whether Jesus was breast-fed, but Church members are now encouraged to use the term "fed pursuant to the mammary gland method" to avoid too-frequent mention of Mary's décolletage.]

"Keep the Commandments?"

Does preaching obedience to commandments produce a change of heart?  Does shaming people improve their behavior?  Then why do we shun wayward souls, thinking our disapproval will motivate them to repent?

Don't let the irony escape you: we think shoving "the law" in others' faces will produce life (when Paul told us it produces death) as if we were scripturally illiterate?

Here's the point: Preaching the gospel is the opposite of preaching the commandments (the law).  That was Paul's whole message: we don't come unto Christ by obedience to the law, but through faith in Him.  The gospel Paul preached was about Christ freeing us from the law, not yoking us to it.

Have we forgotten that Christ came, not to condemn the world, but to save it?  Will we go on deluding ourselves by thinking our religious rigidity makes us licensed physicians to heal sick sinners, when we're just placebo-pill pushers snorting cocaine from a razor blade's edge that we've imagined to be God's own two-edged sword?

Case in point:  My young daughter came to me the other night as I was watching a cooking show on TV in my bedroom; she saw on the television that one of the chefs had a sleeve of tattoos covering his arm.  She said, "Daddy, can you go to heaven if you have tattoos?"

I nearly fell out of bed.  I assure you she didn't pick that up from me; so where would my daughter learn to think that way?

Oh yes: at Church, from her teachers; from ward leadership at "Standards Night."

"Honey," I said.  "Of course you can go to heaven with tattoos!  Christ has engraved us on the palms of his hands.  Maybe one day I'll get one of your name, written on my heart, because I love you so much."

She hopped away happily, but I was left wondering, when did we start measuring a person's worth to be proportional to their ability to "keep the commandments"?
Picture
4 Comments
Ben
6/8/2023 09:51:31 am

"Here's the point: Preaching the gospel is the opposite of preaching the commandments (the law). That was Paul's whole message: we don't come unto Christ by obedience to the law, but through faith in Him. The gospel Paul preached was about Christ freeing us from the law, not yoking us to it."

This is a point I've been trying to consume since I read it. I can't say that I understand this concept. I see the words and while the message is clear, I'm having trouble wrapping my fingers around the implications. I read the words over and over again but I can't get them to stick to anything. I suppose this is a typical symptom of unbelief. But it feels like an important point I need to comprehend. Help thou mine unbelief?

Reply
Tim Merrill
6/8/2023 11:35:37 am

Thanks Ben, your unbelief shows greater faith than that found in all of Israel, I'm sure. I was asking, "Is the gospel about Christ or about keeping the law?" The point I was trying to make was, when the rubber meets the road, what do we trust? Do we trust in the commandments to get us to heaven? Or do we trust in Christ?

In Part 3 (which I just posted) I try to develop this idea a bit further; if we're preaching the commandments to others as if it were the gospel (i.e., telling them to stay on the Covenant Path)("Keep the Sabbath, go to Church, serve in your callings, do your ministering, don't drink alcohol, don't curse, etc.) then what are we saying about the gospel? We're saying the gospel is as efficacious as our obedience to the commandments.

Paul's message was to lift our eyes beyond the law, past the bondage of carnal commandments, and to walk by faith.

Commandments = walking by sight.
Christ = walking by faith.

Now, many people are going to say there's no conflict between the two; in fact, the Bible Dictionary says that faith is a gift that comes based on our obedience. But as Joseph Smith said, "By the proving of contraries is truth made manifest."

This is not about "faith vs. works"; although many will view it that way (I try to avoid that debate, and merely refer others to the Book of James). Instead, what I am saying is, "Don't put our faith in works; don't trust keeping the commandments to turn us into Saints, because the law is powerless to transform our natures, which is through Christ's love."

Reply
Gwendolyn
6/8/2023 05:35:54 pm

A weight-loss analogy is coming to mind (speaking as someone who learned the hard way that nightly ice cream pregnancy weight does not all “just fall off”!):

I can exercise all I want (law), but I will fail to reach my desired weight if I don’t eat (love) correctly. Conversely, I can reach whatever weight goal I have entirely through my eating (love) habits and never break a sweat (law). I have noticed that exercising helps me desire foods that are good for me, and can motivate me to not indulge in eating habits that sabotage my efforts, so it can be wonderfully useful—as long as I understand it’s not “the way” to achieve my goal.

I love reading and pondering your writings on this subject and all others, btw. Thank you and keep going!

Tim Merrill
6/9/2023 08:42:21 am

Gwendolyn: that's a great analogy, the way exercise motivates us to be healthier in other aspects of our lives (not that I am any kind of expert on exercise; though I once was a "raw fooder" who ate only raw things and I actually lasted for three weeks). Man cannot live on cauliflower alone!

It reminds me of Paul saying the law was a "schoolmaster" to bring us to Christ. Perhaps the law provides bumper rails for those of us who keep getting gutter balls. Thank you! Tim

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Tim Merrill

    RSS Feed

    Previous Posts

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020

    RSS Feed

    Previous Posts
Home
© COPYRIGHT 2019 - 2025
  • Home
  • Poetry
    • Fleeing Egypt >
      • Tower of Babel
      • The Orchard
      • Tithing Settlement
      • Chastity for Churches
      • Sign
      • Cleaning House
      • Elijah
      • Rulers of Sodom
      • Beware
      • Two Churches
      • Beginning At My Sanctuary
      • Toll Road
      • Get it Strait
      • Corporation Sole
      • The Religion of the Circle R
      • Fig Tree
      • Eve
      • New Jerusalem
      • Shemlon's Shore
    • Ascending Sinai >
      • Ark
      • Sin of the Calf
      • An Idol Observation
      • Dew from Heaven
      • I love you, Elder Holland
      • Easter
      • How Sweet
      • Haiku
      • The Barn
      • Patron Saint
      • A Conversation with Brigham Young
      • Mine Testimony
      • The Meadow
      • The Gardens
      • Ice Fishing
      • Without End
      • Forest
      • Continental Divide
      • A Great Sacrifice
    • Promised Land >
      • Lanolin
      • Zion
      • Wisdom
      • Take Up Your Cross
      • Was the Sun the Same
      • Plain and Precious
      • Bridegroom
      • Faith
      • Amos
      • But First
      • Wax
      • Parable of the Piano
      • Repentance
      • Wake Up, Child
      • Cold Storage
      • Covered Wagon
      • Multiply and Replenish
      • Rollercoaster
      • The Baptist
    • Seven Stations of the Cross >
      • Jesus Condemned to Die >
        • Life Signs
        • Fashionable Religion
        • Tithing Declaration
        • A Pretty Important Detail
        • Jesus is All
        • Salt Lake Temple
        • Zion in the Lion's Den
        • High Noon
        • Bookmark
      • Jesus Stumbles and Falls >
        • Unveil
        • But Faith
        • Sifting
        • The Ballerina
        • Credit Declined
        • Prayer Circles
        • Work Out Your Salvation
        • Lovebirds
        • Unrequited
      • Simon of Cyrene Bears the Cross >
        • Proxy
        • Chartres
        • Like the Nile
        • Artificial Intelligence
        • Not Born
        • Parable of the Crossing
      • Women of Jerusalem Weep >
        • With A Price
        • Fields of Asphodel
        • Night
        • Desert Rose
        • Goodbye
        • Spring Snow
      • Jesus Stripped of His Garment >
        • Love Letter
        • I am disquieted
        • Dream
        • Noah's Wife
        • Parable of the Five Sons
        • Eggshell
      • Jesus Nailed to the Cross
      • Burial and Resurrection
  • Blog
    • Previous Posts >
      • 2025 Posts
      • 2024 Posts
      • 2023 Posts
      • 2022 Posts
      • 2021 Posts
      • 2020 Posts
  • About
  • Contact